Should I Be Eating Organic?

Shorter Version


Est. Reading Time: 3 Minutes

Are organic apples healthier than conventional apples? Is drinking organic milk the only way to avoid added hormones and antibiotics? There is often confusion with the term “organic.” Organic doesn’t necessarily mean “healthier.” Let’s take a look at what organic really means, its impact on the environment, and how you might decide whether or not to purchase organic products that tend to have a higher price tag.

What does it mean to be eating organic food?

The USDA defines and regulates all organic products in the United States. According to the USDA, organic refers to foods that are “produced using cultural, biological, and mechanical practices that support the cycling of on-farm resources, promote ecological balance, and conserve biodiversity.” Organic foods must meet several requirements to receive a certified seal (“100% organic” or “organic”) or labeling terms (“made with organic” or “organic ingredients”). Long story short, organic refers to food processing, not the health impact.

  • Produce: For produce, organic is defined as grown on soil not containing any prohibited substances such as synthetic pesticides and fertilizers. However, a few approved synthetic substances may be used on certain crops that have been reviewed for any health and environmental effects. (The National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances is here.) Pst! This means organic farmers are still able to use pesticides, both natural and some synthetic.
  • Meat & Poultry: Organic means animals must live in areas that encourage natural behaviors, be fed only 100% organic feed, and not given any hormones or antibiotics.

Contrary to belief, most research states there is not a significant difference in the nutrient content of organic foods when compared to conventional foods. Organic foods do have other benefits. Organic farming involves sustainable practices and avoids genetically modified organisms (GMOs). These foods are a labor of love provided by your local farmers! The higher cost of organics is needed to cover the extra labor for pest control and weeding, receiving the USDA organic certification, and account for crop losses. But, as the number of organic farms continues to grow, we’ll start to see these prices go down due to more availability.

You’ll want to lean towards organic in order to make a positive impact on the environment and support your local farmers.

What does this mean for conventional food?

Let’s look at conventional foods. While these foods do use synthetic sources for successful growth, their processing involves safe practices for the consumer. The USDA regulates all substances that are used on the foods we eat and works hard to prevent harmful foods from making it into consumer’s hands. They even release an Annual Summary of their Pesticide Data Program showcasing samples tested for pesticide residue. And guess what? The latest survey (2017) stated that 99% of tested samples were below the Environmental Protection Agency’s tolerance levels. But despite the reports, there is still controversy among consumers. (FYI: The FDA also inspects foreign foods, especially from countries that do not have similar food safety systems. Read more about their goals to improve that process here.) With supermarkets on every corner, it makes monitoring everything difficult, so it’s important to practice safe food handling with both conventional and organic foods.

The best way to rid your foods of any residue is to wash, wash, wash. First, wash your hands thoroughly, then wash the produce under running water continuing to massage or scrub with a brush. Always wash produce before peeling or slicing to avoid transferring the dirt from the knife or peeler onto the edible portion. For heads of leafy greens, throw away the outer leaves. Residues also like to hide out in animal fat, so trim the fat and skin from meats, fish, and poultry.

Go ahead, eat organic! Or don’t. It’s a personal preference. But you’ll want to lean towards organic in order to make a positive impact on the environment and support your local farmers.

Longer Version


Est. Reading Time: 5 Minutes

Are organic foods better for you than conventional foods? There is often confusion with the term “organic.” Organic doesn’t necessarily mean “healthier.” Let’s take a look at what organic really means, its impact on the environment, and how you might decide whether or not to purchase organic products that tend to have a higher price tag.

What does it mean to be eating organic food?

The USDA defines and regulates all organic products in the United States. According to the USDA, organic refers to foods that are “produced using cultural, biological, and mechanical practices that support the cycling of on-farm resources, promote ecological balance, and conserve biodiversity.” Organic foods must meet several requirements to receive a certified seal (“100% organic” or “organic”) or labeling terms (“made with organic” or “organic ingredients”). Long story short, organic refers to food processing, not the health impact.

  • Produce: For produce, organic is defined as grown in soil that does not contain any prohibited substances, such as synthetic pesticides and fertilizers. Instead, farmers have to rely on biologically derived pesticides that break down faster and are generally safer for non-target organisms. However, a few approved synthetic substances may be used on certain crops that have been reviewed for any health and environmental effects. (The National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances is here.)
  • Meat & Poultry: Organic means animals must live in areas that encourage natural behaviors, be fed only 100% organic feed, and not given any hormones or antibiotics.

Organic farming involves sustainable practices and avoids the use of genetically modified organisms (GMOs). These foods are typically provided by your local farmers. And the higher cost of organics is needed to cover the extra labor for pest control and weeding, receiving the USDA organic certification, and accounting for crop losses. But as the number of organic farms continues to grow, we’ll start to see these prices decline due to greater availability.

You’ll want to lean toward organic to make a positive impact on the environment and support your local farmers.

What does this mean for conventional food?

Let’s look at conventional foods. While these foods do use synthetic sources for successful growth, their processing follows safe practices for consumers. The USDA regulates all substances used in the foods we eat and works hard to prevent harmful foods from reaching consumers. They even release an Annual Summary of their Pesticide Data Program, which showcases samples tested for pesticide residues. And guess what? The latest survey (2024) stated that 99% of tested samples were below the Environmental Protection Agency’s tolerance levels, with 42.3% having no detectable residue. Despite the reports, controversy persists among consumers. With supermarkets on every corner, monitoring everything is difficult, so it’s important to practice safe food handling with both conventional and organic foods.

What are the health impacts?

Several studies have found measurable differences in nutrient content between organic and conventionally grown foods. For example, organically grown crops can contain about 69% higher concentrations of antioxidant compounds such as polyphenols and flavonoids, while also being around 30% lower in nitrates (high nitrate levels have been associated with increased risk of certain cancers). Certain micronutrients are also consistently higher in organic produce, including vitamin C, magnesium, and iron. And it’s not just produce; organic dairy products and meats have also been shown to contain more omega-3 fatty acids and less saturated fat, likely because animals are more often grass-fed. And, obviously, organic foods tend to contain lower levels of pesticide residues than conventional foods.

When researchers look at long-term health outcomes, the evidence is still developing, but some interesting patterns have emerged. A systematic review containing results from clinical trials and observational studies has found that people who consume more organic foods have lower rates of metabolic syndrome, obesity, allergic sensitization, and some pregnancy complications such as infertility and pre-eclampsia. They also observed a lower incidence of non-Hodgkin lymphoma and possibly postmenopausal breast cancer among frequent organic food consumers. However, scientists caution that these studies cannot prove organic food itself is responsible, since people who choose organic foods often also eat more fruits and vegetables, exercise more, and follow generally healthier lifestyles.

One of the clearest differences between organic and conventional foods is the level of pesticide exposure. Studies show that switching from a conventional to an organic diet can significantly reduce the levels of pesticide metabolites detected in urine within a few days. While most pesticide levels in food are regulated to remain below safety thresholds, researchers continue to study the effects of long-term exposure. Repetitive pesticide exposure has been linked to neurological disorders, hormone disruption, reproductive problems, and some cancers, especially in agricultural workers. Pesticide use is also heavily associated with negative impacts on biodiversity. These chemicals can move through soil and waterways, affecting insects, birds, fish, and other wildlife. In particular, pesticide exposure has been associated with declines in pollinators and other species that are essential for healthy ecosystems and food production.

What should you do?

The best way to rid your foods of any residue is to wash, wash, wash. First, wash your hands thoroughly, then wash the produce under running water, continuing to massage or scrub with your hands. Always wash produce before peeling or slicing to avoid transferring the dirt from the knife or peeler onto the edible portion. For heads of leafy greens, throw away the outer leaves. Residues also like to hide out in animal fat, so trim the fat and skin from meats, fish, and poultry.

Go ahead, eat organic! Or don’t. It’s a personal preference. But you’ll want to lean toward organic to make a positive impact on the environment and support your local farmers

Actionable Steps


  1. Prioritize: Prioritize your organics. If price is a concern, choose the items that are most important to you or that raise the most environmental concerns. Start eating organic foods for the ones you eat most often. Some organic shoppers like to use the Environmental Working Group’s Dirty Dozen and Clean Fifteen as a starting point, but remember that even these conventional counterparts are safe to eat when washed thoroughly.
  2. Study your vocabulary: Before you go shopping, use these resources to understand the certified USDA Organic labels and how to weed out any marketing terms like “made with organic” or “organic ingredients.”
  3. Wash, wash, wash: Wash ALL your fruits and veggies just before eating, even when eating organic. Get the rundown on washing with this quick video.
  4. Explore more: Visit our articles and recipes page for additional science-backed insights, including related topics such as How To Reduce Food Waste, Tips For Eating Healthy On A Budget, and What You Need To Know About Trending Diets.
  5. Take other parts of your health seriously: Visit our services page and schedule an appointment with one of our doctors, nurses, or coaches.

Sources


  1. https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2016/07/22/understanding-usda-organic-label
  2. https://www.ams.usda.gov/datasets/pdp/pdpdata
  3. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/PDPAnnualSummary.pdf
  4. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/what-is-organic-food#more-nutrients
  5. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10814746/
  6. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7019963/
  7. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11664077/
  8. https://www.pan-europe.info/issues/pesticides-and-loss-biodiversity

This article was originally written by Shannon Costello for Guide, Inc., and was updated for use by Meakin Metabolic Care by Aubrey Christofferson.

Related Categories: Expert Article

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice. Always consult your clinician before making any medical or medication decisions.